Tony's Pizza Elizabeth City

Located in the heart of Elizabeth City, Tony's Pizza Elizabeth City is a must-visit destination for lovers of authentic Italian cuisine and classic, mouthwatering pizza. This welcoming Italian restaurant brings a genuine Jersey vibe to the area, a sentiment echoed by long-time patrons who have found a true taste of home in their warm, inviting atmosphere.

At Tony's Pizza, the menu is a celebration of hearty, well-crafted dishes that effortlessly blend tradition with comfort. Whether you’re craving the quintessential Large Pepperoni Pizza — topped with a generous layer of flavorful pepperoni and just the right amount of cheese — or prefer something more indulgent like the Chicken Marsala or the richly sauced Stuffed Shells, every bite offers a comforting embrace of familiar Italian flavors. Fans of pasta won’t be disappointed with their perfectly cooked Linguine with Clam Sauce or the classic Spaghetti with Meatballs, each dish delivering robust, savory notes that linger pleasantly on the palate.

Beyond the classics, Tony’s also dazzles with a broad selection that includes the Chicken Alfredo featuring mushrooms and onions, juicy Hamburger Steaks, and the ever-popular Calzone with ham. Their menu also showcases flavorful sandwiches, such as the hearty Philly Cheesesteak Sub and a crispy Fried Chicken Sandwich, ensuring there’s something for everyone.

The dining atmosphere at Tony's Pizza mirrors a true neighborhood gem — warm, relaxed, and filled with the friendly buzz of satisfied customers sharing stories over great food. Reviewers frequently mention the attentive and courteous service, with specific praise for staff like Stephanie, who not only provide excellent care but also enhance the overall dining experience with their genuine warmth.

Locals appreciate the ample parking and convenient carry-out options, making Tony’s a go-to spot whether you’re planning a cozy meal in or grabbing a fresh, hot pizza to enjoy at home. For those longing for an authentic Italian experience reminiscent of the Tri-State area, Tony's Pizza Elizabeth City delivers with every bite — a proud standout in the local dining scene that promises to welcome you back time and again.